Cash Balance Pension Plan
Definition
A Cash Balance Pension Plan is a type of hybrid pension plan that combines features of traditional defined benefit plans with characteristics of defined contribution plans. Under this plan, each participant’s benefit is expressed as a hypothetical individual account balance, which grows over time with pay credits (based on a percentage of annual compensation) and interest credits (based on a predetermined formula or rate). Unlike typical defined contribution plans, these hypothetical accounts do not need to be pre-funded during the participant’s employment but are usually fully paid out upon termination or retirement.
Examples
-
Employer A offers a cash balance pension plan where each employee receives pay credits equivalent to 5% of their salary and interest credits based on the rate of a 10-year Treasury bond plus 1%. Employee X, earning $100,000 annually, would see a hypothetical account balance increase by $5,000 in pay credits and additional interest credits as determined by the bond rate.
-
Company B has a cash balance plan that includes a flat 4% pay credit for all employees and a fixed 3% interest credit added annually. Employee Y with a consistent salary of $75,000 would accumulate a $3,000/year increase from pay credits and growth based on the 3% annual interest addition.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: How is a cash balance pension plan different from a traditional defined benefit plan?
A1: While a traditional defined benefit plan provides a fixed monthly benefit at retirement based on salary and years of service, a cash balance plan defines retirement benefits in terms of a hypothetical account balance that grows with pay and interest credits.
Q2: Can employees contribute to their cash balance pension plans?
A2: Typically, cash balance pension plans are funded solely by the employer, reflecting hypothetical credits rather than actual individual contributions. However, some employers may combine them with 401(k) or other defined contribution plans where employee contributions are allowed.
Q3: What happens to a cash balance pension plan if an employee leaves the company before retirement?
A3: Employees who leave before retirement are often entitled to the vested portion of their account balance, which can be rolled into another retirement account or taken as a lump sum distribution, subject to plan specifics and regulatory requirements.
Q4: How are the interest credits for a cash balance pension plan determined?
A4: Interest credits can be based on a fixed rate, the performance of a specified financial index, or other factors such as the return on U.S. Treasury bonds. The rate and method of calculation are detailed in the plan document.
Q5: Is the hypothetical account balance in a cash balance plan guaranteed?
A5: Yes, employers are typically responsible for ensuring that the account balances meet the promised pay and interest credits, meaning they bear the investment risk and the obligation to pay the guaranteed amount upon termination or retirement.
-
Defined Benefit Plan: A retirement plan that promises a specified monthly benefit upon retirement, usually based on salary and years of service.
-
Defined Contribution Plan: A retirement plan where the amount contributed is defined, but the benefit received at retirement depends on investment performance.
-
Vesting: The process by which an employee accrues non-forfeitable rights over employer-provided pension benefits, usually based on years of service.
Online References
- Investopedia - Cash Balance Pension Plan
- U.S. Department of Labor - Cash Balance Plans
Suggested Books for Further Studies
- “The New Health Care System: Everything You Need to Know” by David Nather
- “Retirement Plans: 401(k)s, IRAs, and Other Deferred Compensation Approaches” by Allen L. Silvers
Fundamentals of Cash Balance Pension Plan: Pension Plans Basics Quiz
### What kind of retirement plan defines benefits in a hypothetical account balance increased by pay and interest credits?
- [x] Cash Balance Pension Plan
- [ ] 401(k) Plan
- [ ] Traditional Defined Benefit Plan
- [ ] Profit-Sharing Plan
> **Explanation:** A Cash Balance Pension Plan provides benefits based on a hypothetical account balance that grows with pay and interest credits.
### Who typically funds a cash balance pension plan?
- [ ] Employees
- [x] Employers
- [ ] Both Employees and Employers
- [ ] The Government
> **Explanation:** Cash balance pension plans are primarily funded by employers, who provide the pay and interest credits.
### How is the interest credit in a cash balance plan commonly determined?
- [ ] Fixed percentage only
- [ ] Employee's investment choices
- [x] Predetermined rates such as fixed rates or financial indices
- [ ] Monthly market performance
> **Explanation:** Interest credits in cash balance plans are often based on predetermined rates, such as a fixed percentage or the performance of specific financial indices.
### What is the main difference between a defined contribution plan and a cash balance pension plan?
- [x] Defined contribution is based on actual contributions and investment returns; cash balance is based on hypothetical credits.
- [ ] Both are funded by employees only.
- [ ] Cash balance plans require employee contributions, defined contribution plans do not.
- [ ] There is no significant difference in their structure.
> **Explanation:** Defined contribution plans are based on actual contributions and investment returns, whereas cash balance plans use hypothetical credits.
### In the event of an employee's termination before retirement, how is their cash balance pension plan handled?
- [ ] It is forfeited completely.
- [ ] Rolled into a specified government fund.
- [x] The vested portion is usually paid out or rolled over to another retirement account.
- [ ] Lost if terminated before qualifying age.
> **Explanation:** Employees who leave before retirement are generally entitled to the vested portion of their cash balance pension plan, which can be paid out or transferred to another retirement account.
### What does the "vesting" period in a cash balance pension plan determine?
- [x] The period employees must work before they have accrued non-forfeitable rights to the benefits.
- [ ] The amount of pay credits allocated.
- [ ] The interest rate applied to credits.
- [ ] The total payout at retirement.
> **Explanation:** The vesting period determines the duration an employee must work to earn non-forfeitable rights to the benefits provided in the plan.
### Which characteristic best describes a cash balance pension plan?
- [ ] Fixed monthly retirement income based on salary
- [ ] Investment choices are made by employees
- [x] Hypothetical account with employer-funded credits
- [ ] Only available for government employees
> **Explanation:** Cash balance pension plans feature hypothetical accounts funded by employers through pay and interest credits.
### Why might a company prefer offering a cash balance pension plan over a traditional defined benefit plan?
- [x] It can be more cost-predictive and help attract a younger workforce.
- [ ] It favors long-term employees more.
- [ ] Less regulatory oversight.
- [ ] Guarantees a higher payout than all other plans.
> **Explanation:** Companies might prefer cash balance plans as they can offer more predictable costs and are appealing to younger workers who prefer seeing account balances grow.
### How does a cash balance pension plan benefit employees in terms of payouts?
- [ ] Provides less flexibility in payout options than lump sum payments.
- [ ] Requires continued employment for benefits.
- [x] Allows for various payout options, including lump sums or annuities.
- [ ] Only offers annuities as payout.
> **Explanation:** Cash balance pension plans can provide employees with flexible payout options, such as lump sums or converting their balance to annuities.
### What type of investment risk do participants in cash balance pension plans typically bear?
- [ ] High because they choose their investments.
- [ ] Moderate because they can influence interest credits.
- [x] Low because employers bear the investment risk.
- [ ] Equally shared with the employer.
> **Explanation:** Participants in cash balance pension plans usually bear low investment risk as the employer guarantees the pay and interest credits.
Thank you for exploring the fundamentals of cash balance pension plans and testing your knowledge with our quiz. Keep learning to secure your financial future!
