Short-Sale Rule

Short-Sale Rule Plus-Tick Rule SEC Regulation Short Selling Stock Market Rules
The short-sale rule, often known as the plus-tick rule, was a regulation enforced by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) requiring that short sales be made only in a rising market. This rule aimed to prevent the manipulation and excessive downward pressure on stock prices.
On this page

Definition

The short-sale rule, also known as the plus-tick rule, was a regulation implemented by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) that required short sales of securities to be executed only in a market that is on an uptick. Specifically, short sales could only be made at a higher price than the last traded price or on a price equal to the last trade if the price was higher than the previous price. This rule was designed to prevent excessive downward pressure on stock prices from aggressive short selling. The SEC rescinded the rule in 2007, removing the requirement.

Examples

  1. Scenario 1: An investor wants to short sell ABC Corp. stock, but the last trade price was $15.30, down from a previous trade of $15.35. Under the short-sale rule, the investor would have to wait until the stock price ticked up to at least $15.31 before executing the short sale.

  2. Scenario 2: In a volatile market, XYZ Inc. shares are trading erratically. With the short-sale rule in place, traders looking to short XYZ Inc. would have to track every trade and only place their short-sale orders at a price incrementally higher than the previous uptick.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What was the primary purpose of the short-sale rule? The primary purpose of the short-sale rule was to prevent market manipulation and avoid exacerbating downward trends in stock prices through aggressive short selling.

2. Why was the short-sale rule rescinded? The SEC rescinded the short-sale rule in 2007 because they concluded that the rule was no longer effective in maintaining an orderly market, particularly in the face of advancing trading technologies and market conditions.

3. What does ‘up-tick’ mean in the context of the short-sale rule? An uptick refers to a stock transaction occurring at a higher price than the previous trade. The short-sale rule mandated that short sales could only occur on such upticks.

4. Are there any alternatives to the short-sale rule in place today? After the rescindment of the short-sale rule, the SEC introduced circuit breakers and alternative short selling restrictions such as the uptick rule, applicable during significant price declines to temporary restrict short selling.

  • Short Selling: The practice of selling securities or other financial instruments that are not currently owned, with the intention of buying them back later at a lower price.
  • Circuit Breaker: Mechanisms in stock markets triggered to temporarily halt trading following unusual price movements which serve to curb panic-selling and extreme volatility.
  • Uptick Rule: A trading restriction requiring that every short sale transaction be entered at a price higher than the last trade price, intended to control the potential market destabilization caused by short selling.

Online Resources

  1. SEC.gov - Short Sales
  2. Investopedia - Short-Selling
  3. Wikipedia - Short-Selling

Suggested Books for Further Studies

  1. “The Short Selling Bible: Uncover the Secret Strategies for Profiting from Market Declines” by Rick Rickertsen
  2. “Reminiscences of a Stock Operator” by Edwin Lefèvre
  3. “Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of Risk” by Peter L. Bernstein

Fundamentals of Short-Sale Rule: Finance Basics Quiz

### What was the purpose of the short-sale rule? - [ ] To prevent buying high - [x] To prevent excessive downward market pressure - [ ] To restrict stock trading during trading hours - [ ] To ensure equal buy and sell trades > **Explanation:** The short-sale rule was designed to prevent excessive downward pressure on stock prices, thereby curbing market manipulation through aggressive short selling. ### When was the short-sale rule rescinded by the SEC? - [ ] 2005 - [ ] 2000 - [ ] 2010 - [x] 2007 > **Explanation:** The short-sale rule was rescinded by the SEC in 2007 after they concluded the rule was outdated with advancing market conditions and trading technologies. ### The short-sale rule is also known by which other name? - [x] Plus-Tick Rule - [ ] Downtick Rule - [ ] Flash Crash Rule - [ ] Circuit Breaker Rule > **Explanation:** The short-sale rule is also commonly referred to as the plus-tick rule because it allowed short sales to be executed only if the last trade price was higher than the previous price. ### Can an investor short sell a stock if the market is on a downtick under the short-sale rule? - [ ] Yes - [x] No - [ ] Only after approval - [ ] Only on certain days > **Explanation:** Under the short-sale rule, an investor could not short sell a stock if the market was on a downtick. The sale had to occur in an uptick condition. ### Explain the term 'uptick' in the context of short selling. - [ ] A price lower than the previous trade - [x] A price higher than the previous trade - [ ] An expired trade option - [ ] A continuous price decline > **Explanation:** In the context of short selling, an uptick means a price higher than the previous trade. The short-sale rule mandated that sales could only happen during such upticks. ### What replaced the short-sale rule after it was rescinded? - [ ] Free-for-all trading - [ ] Complete ban on short selling - [x] Temporary uptick rule and circuit breakers - [ ] New SEC trading deadlines > **Explanation:** After the short-sale rule was rescinded, temporary uptick rules and circuit breakers were introduced to handle significant price declines and curb market destabilization. ### What aspect of the market did short-sale rule primarily target? - [ ] Trading volume - [ ] Dividend Issuance - [x] Market manipulation through short selling - [ ] Stock Buybacks > **Explanation:** The short-sale rule primarily targeted market manipulation through short selling by preventing excessive downward pressure and manipulation. ### Provide an example where an investor would need to wait under the short-sale rule. - [x] The stock price drops from $20 to $19.5 - [ ] The stock price rises from $15 to $16 - [ ] The stock remains flat at $25 - [ ] The stock price rises from $30 to $31 > **Explanation:** Under the short-sale rule, an investor would need to wait for a price uptick in case the stock price drops, such as from $20 to $19.5, before making a short sale. ### What is the primary benefit of short selling in finance? - [ ] Reducing taxes - [ ] Increasing trade volume - [ ] Diversifying investments - [x] Profiting from a declining stock price > **Explanation:** The primary benefit of short selling in finance is the opportunity to profit from a decline in a stock's price, as investors sell borrowed shares at a higher price, intending to buy them back lower. ### Who implemented and rescinded the short-sale rule? - [ ] Federal Reserve - [ ] Department of Commerce - [ ] CFTC - [x] SEC > **Explanation:** The short-sale rule was implemented and rescinded by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the regulatory body overseeing securities laws and stock market operations.

Thank you for exploring the intricacies of the short-sale rule and testing your comprehension with our finance basics quiz. Continue enhancing your financial acumen!

Wednesday, August 7, 2024
Short-Term Capital Gain (Loss)
Short-Form Audit Report

Accounting Terms Lexicon

Discover comprehensive accounting definitions and practical insights. Empowering students and professionals with clear and concise explanations for a better understanding of financial terms.